Efficiency and Factors for Agricultural Use of Sludge in Circular Bulgarian Economy
Despite their relevance, in-depth studies of diverse effects and factors of sludge utilization in Bulgarian agriculture are at an early stage. This paper presents results of a large-scale study aimed at determining socio-economic effects of sludge utilization in Bulgarian agriculture. First, an approach is presented to assess the multilateral effects, efficiencies and factors of sludge utilization in agriculture. Then various factors stimulating and limiting the utilization of sludge in Bulgarian farms are identified. Results of a case study of a holding using sludge as fertilizer are then presented. Based on a qualitative analysis of regulations and institutional structure, and surveys with managers and experts of urban wastewater treatment plants, and farmers using and not-using sludge, the institutional, political, organizational, personal, educational, informational, social, economic, and environmental factors influencing agricultural sludge utilization in two regions (Sofia and Burgas) are identified. Impact factors are generally divided: factors influencing the behavior of agents, and factors determining the type and extent of the effects of sludge use in agriculture. Research is to continue and deepen to establish the economic, sectoral and regional specificities on the basis of more representative information from all participants and interested parties in effective utilization of sludge in the country.
Bachev, H., Ivanov, B. 2021. Efficiency and Factors for Agricultural Use of Sludge in Circular Bulgarian Economy Journal of Applied Economic Sciences, Volume XVI, Fall, 3(73): 280– 301. https://doi.org/10.57017/jaes.v16.3(73).04
Article’s history:
Received 1st of August, 2021; Received in revised form 17th of August, 2021; Accepted 29th of September, 2021. Published 15th of October, 2021. All rights reserved to the Publishing House.
[1] Bachev, H., B. Ivanov, D. Mitova, I. Boevski, P. Marinov, A. Sarov, D. Tsvyatkova, K. Kostenarov, D. Vanev. 2021. Mechanisms and forms of management of agro-ecosystem services in Bulgaria, IAE, Sofia. Башев, Х., Б. Иванов, Д. Митова, И. Боевски, П. Маринов, А. Саров, Д. Цвяткова, К. Костенаров, Д. Ванев. 2021. Механизми и форми на управление на агроекосистемните услуги в България, ИАИ, София.
[2] Bachev H. 2021. Governing of agro-ecosystem services in Bulgaria, Research Topics in Agricultural and Applied Economics, 3: 94-129.
[3] Bachev, H. 2009. Mechanisms of governance of sustainable development, Journal of Applied Economic Sciences, Volume IV, Summer, Issue, 2(8): 169-184.
[4] Bachev, H. 2011. Water governance in Bulgarian agriculture, Climate Change and its Effects on Water Resources, Springer, 215-224.
[5] Bachev, H. 2013. Risk management in the agri-food sector, Contemporary Economics, 7(1): 45-62.
[6] Bachev, H. 2014. Environmental Management in Agriculture - Mechanisms, Forms and Efficiency, LAP LAMBERT Academic Publishing.
[7] Bachev, H. 2017. Socio-economic and environmental sustainability of Bulgarian farms, Agricultural and Resource Economics: International Scientific E-Journal, 29: 5-21.
[8] Bachev, H. 2018. Institutional environment and climate change impacts on sustainability of Bulgarian agriculture, Bulgarian Journal of Agricultural Science, 24(4): 523-533.
[9] Bachev, H., D. Terziev. 2018. A study on agrarian sustainability impact of governance modes in Bulgaria, Journal of Applied Economic Sciences, Volume XII, Spring, 1(55): 227-257.
[10] Bachev, H. 2021. Modes of governance for ecosystem services in Bulgarian farms, Economic Studies, 30(8): 145-174.
[11] Sarov, A. 2020. Socio-economic, environmental and managerial aspects in the utilization of sludge in agriculture, obtained from wastewater treatment, Economics and Management of Agriculture, 1: 58-69. Сяров, А. 2020.Социално-икономически, екологични и управленчески аспекти при оползотворяването на утайки в земеделието, получени при пречистване на отпадъчни води, Икономика и управление на селското стопанство, 1: 58-69.
[12] Ekane, N., Barquet, K., and Rosemarin, A. 2021. Resources and risks: Perceptions on the application of sewage sludge on agricultural land in Sweden, a case study, Front. Sustain. Food Syst., 19 April.
[13] Hudcová, H., Vymazal, J., Miloš Rozkošný. 2019. Present restrictions of sewage sludge application in agriculture within the European Union, Soil and Water Research, 14(2): 104–120.
[14] Iticescu C., Georgescu, P., Arseni, M., Rosu, A., Timofti, M., Carp, G., Cioca, L. 2021. Optimal solutions for the use of sewage sludge on agricultural lands. Water, 13: 585. DOI: https://doi.org/ 10.3390/w13050585. Available at: file:///C:/Users/ASERS1/Downloads/water-13-00585-v2.pdf
[15] Ivanov, B., and Bachev, H. 2021. Convergent analysis of waste water practices among EU countries, Bulgarian Journal of Agricultural Science, 27(2): 289–296.
[16] Marinova, S. 2008. Sludges from wastewater treatment plants and rules for their utilization, Sofia. Маринова, С. 2008. Утайки от пречиствателни станции за отпадъчни води и правила за тяхното оползотворяване, София.
[17] Ivanov, B., Marinova, C., Bachev, X., Georgieva B. 2020. Economic and ecological effects of sludge use in agriculture, Ecological Engineering and Environmental Protection, 3: 44-53. Иванов, Б., Маринова, C., Башев, X., Георгиева B. 2020. Икономически и екологични ефекти от използване на утайките в земеделието, Екологично инженерство и опазване на околната среда, 3: 44-53.
[18] Rosiek, K. 2020. Directions and challenges in the management of municipal sewage sludge in Poland in the context of the circular economy, Sustainability, 12: 3686.
[19] Rosemarin, A., Macura, B., Carolus, J., Barquet, K., et al. 2020. Circular nutrient solutions for agriculture and wastewater – A review of technologies and practices, Current Opinion in Environmental Sustainability, 45: 78-91.
[20] Taşeli, B. 2020. Comparative life cycle assessment of sewage sludge (Biosolid) management options, Intech, Available at: https://www.intechopen.com/chapters/71033.
[21] Tesfamariam, E., Ogbazghi, Z., Annandale, J., Gebrehiwot, Y. 2020. Cost–benefit analysis of municipal sludge as a low-grade nutrient source: A Case Study from South Africa, Sustainability, 12: 9950.
[22] Usman, K., Khan, S., Ghulam, S., Umar, M., Khan, N., Khalil, S. 2012. Sewage sludge: An Important biological resource for sustainable agriculture and its environmental implications, American Journal of Plant Sciences, 3: 1708-1721.
*** ANSES, Sewage sludge produced during the COVID-19 epidemic can only be applied to fields after disinfection, The French Agency for Food, Environmental and Occupational Health & Safety, 02/04/2020.
*** Directive 86/278 / EEC, Directive 86/278/EEC on the protection of the environment and of the soil in particular, in the case of the use of sewage sludge in agriculture. Директива 86/278/ЕИО, Директива 86/278/ ЕИО за опазване на околната среда и в частност на почвите, в случаите на употреба на утайки от отпадъчни води в земеделието.
*** EU Roundtable discussion on sludge use. Available at: https://ec.europa.eu/environment/archives/waste/ sludge/pdf/workshoppart5.pdf
*** Eur Eau. 2021. Water treatment – sludge management. Eur Eau.
*** EС, Environmental, economic and social impacts of the use of sewage sludge on land. Available at: https://ec.europa.eu/environment/archives/waste/sludge/pdf/part_i_report.pdf
*** NSPSMWTP, National Strategic Plan for Sludge Management from Wastewater Treatment Plants in Bulgaria for the period 2014-2020. НСПУУ, Национален стратегически план за управление на утайки от пречиствателните станции за отпадъчни води в България за периода 2014- 2020г.
*** Ordinance on the procedure and manner of utilization of sludge from wastewater treatment through their use in agriculture, adopted by Council of Ministers № 201 of 04.08.2016. Наредба за реда и начина за оползотворяване на утайки от пречистването на отпадъчни води чрез употребата им в земеделието, приета с ПМС № 201 от 04.08.2016г.
*** IAE, Opportunities for the utilization of sludge obtained from wastewater treatment and the effect on sustainable agriculture, report of a scientific-applied project, IAI, 2021. ИАИ, Възможности от оползотворяването на утайки, получени при пречистване на отпадъчни води и ефект за устойчиво земеделие, отчет на научно-приложен проект, ИАИ, 2021.
*** EEA, Report from the Executive Environment Agency on Article 16, paragraph 2 of the Ordinance on the procedure and manner of utilization of sludge from wastewater treatment through their use in agriculture, Sofia 2019. ИАОС, Доклад от изпълнителна агенция по околна среда относно чл.16, ал.2 от наредба за реда и начина за оползотворяване на утайки от пречистването на отпадъчни води чрез употребата им в земеделието, София 2019г.
*** The European Green Deal, Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament, the European Council, the Council, the European Economic and Social Committee and the Committee of the Regions, European Commission, 11.12.2019.